一、未校验:配置证书就能抓
1.这种情况是最简单的情况,Android 7.0之前的设备,直接配置用户证书,就能进行抓包,Android 7.0之后的设备,需要获取root权限1后,把用户证书移到系统证书目录下,或者配置系统强制信任用户证书。对于移动用户证书到系统证书目录下的情况,推荐使用这个插件:https://github.com/ys1231/MoveCertificate,对于强制信任用户证书的这种情况,推荐使用这个插件:https://github.com/NVISOsecurity/MagiskTrustUserCerts。
2.对于这种情况,我们安装完证书后,直接使用代理/vpn的方式进行抓包就可以了,这里我们以via浏览器为例,进行抓包演示,因为我用的设备是Android 7.0以上的,所以我们首先是配置系统强制信任用户证书的插件
3.配置完成后,我们在抓包软件上导出证书,然后在设备上进行安装。
4.接下来,我们就可以进行抓包了,抓包成功。
二、单向证书认证:客户端校验服务器证书--SSL Pinning
1.这是第二种情况,也就是我们常说的sslpinning,想具体了解sslpining技术,可以去看这2篇文章:https://shunix.com/ssl-pinning/,https://yu-jack.github.io/2020/03/02/ssl-pinning/。
2.针对这种情况,我们以滴答清单app为例,进行抓包,上面我们已经试过了,用我们的测试设备是可以正常抓到https的数据包的,然后我们再去抓一下滴答清单这个app的包,点击发送验证码按钮后会提示发送失败,请重试 ,说明我们抓包失败了。
3.这里报错:Client closed the connection before a request was made. Possibly the SSL certificate was rejected,表明在 SSL/TLS 握手阶段,客户端在没有发送 HTTP 请求之前就关闭了连接,客户端拒绝了服务器的证书,也就是上面我们所说的sslpinning技术,还有另外一种报错的情况:SSL handshake with client failed: An unknown issue occurred processing the certificate (certificate_unknown),也是用到了sslpinning技术。那遇到上述这2种情况,我们应该怎么处理呢?使用frida进行hook,我们这里直接用大佬们写好的脚本进行hook
Java.perform(function() {
/*
hook list:
1.SSLcontext
2.okhttp
3.webview
4.XUtils
5.httpclientandroidlib
6.JSSE
7.network_security_config (android 7.0+)
8.Apache Http client (support partly)
9.OpenSSLSocketImpl
10.TrustKit
11.Cronet
*/
// Attempts to bypass SSL pinning implementations in a number of
// ways. These include implementing a new TrustManager that will
// accept any SSL certificate, overriding OkHTTP v3 check()
// method etc.
var X509TrustManager = Java.use('javax.net.ssl.X509TrustManager');
var HostnameVerifier = Java.use('javax.net.ssl.HostnameVerifier');
var SSLContext = Java.use('javax.net.ssl.SSLContext');
var quiet_output = false;
// Helper method to honor the quiet flag.
function quiet_send(data) {
if (quiet_output) {
return;
}
send(data)
}
// Implement a new TrustManager
// ref: https://gist.github.com/oleavr/3ca67a173ff7d207c6b8c3b0ca65a9d8
// Java.registerClass() is only supported on ART for now(201803). 所以android 4.4以下不兼容,4.4要切换成ART使用.
/*
06-07 16:15:38.541 27021-27073/mi.sslpinningdemo W/System.err: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Required method checkServerTrusted(X509Certificate[], String, String, String) missing
06-07 16:15:38.542 27021-27073/mi.sslpinningdemo W/System.err: at android.net.http.X509TrustManagerExtensions.(X509TrustManagerExtensions.java:73)
at mi.ssl.MiPinningTrustManger.(MiPinningTrustManger.java:61)
06-07 16:15:38.543 27021-27073/mi.sslpinningdemo W/System.err: at mi.sslpinningdemo.OkHttpUtil.getSecPinningClient(OkHttpUtil.java:112)
at mi.sslpinningdemo.OkHttpUtil.get(OkHttpUtil.java:62)
at mi.sslpinningdemo.MainActivity$1$1.run(MainActivity.java:36)
*/
var X509Certificate = Java.use("java.security.cert.X509Certificate");
var TrustManager;
try {
TrustManager = Java.registerClass({
name: 'org.wooyun.TrustManager',
implements: [X509TrustManager],
methods: {
checkClientTrusted: function(chain, authType) {},
checkServerTrusted: function(chain, authType) {},
getAcceptedIssuers: function() {
// var certs = [X509Certificate.$new()];
// return certs;
return [];
}
}
});
} catch (e) {
quiet_send("registerClass from X509TrustManager >>>>>>>> " + e.message);
}
// Prepare the TrustManagers array to pass to SSLContext.init()
var TrustManagers = [TrustManager.$new()];
try {
// Prepare a Empty SSLFactory
var TLS_SSLContext = SSLContext.getInstance("TLS");
TLS_SSLContext.init(null, TrustManagers, null);
var EmptySSLFactory = TLS_SSLContext.getSocketFactory();
} catch (e) {
quiet_send(e.message);
}
send('Custom, Empty TrustManager ready');
// Get a handle on the init() on the SSLContext class
var SSLContext_init = SSLContext.init.overload(
'[Ljavax.net.ssl.KeyManager;', '[Ljavax.net.ssl.TrustManager;', 'java.security.SecureRandom');
// Override the init method, specifying our new TrustManager
SSLContext_init.implementation = function(keyManager, trustManager, secureRandom) {
quiet_send('Overriding SSLContext.init() with the custom TrustManager');
SSLContext_init.call(this, null, TrustManagers, null);
};
/*** okhttp3.x unpinning ***/
// Wrap the logic in a try/catch as not all applications will have
// okhttp as part of the app.
try {
var CertificatePinner = Java.use('okhttp3.CertificatePinner');
quiet_send('OkHTTP 3.x Found');
CertificatePinner.check.overload('java.lang.String', 'java.util.List').implementation = function() {
quiet_send('OkHTTP 3.x check() called. Not throwing an exception.');
}
} catch (err) {
// If we dont have a ClassNotFoundException exception, raise the
// problem encountered.
if (err.message.indexOf('ClassNotFoundException') === 0) {
throw new Error(err);
}
}
// Appcelerator Titanium PinningTrustManager
// Wrap the logic in a try/catch as not all applications will have
// appcelerator as part of the app.
try {
var PinningTrustManager = Java.use('appcelerator.https.PinningTrustManager');
send('Appcelerator Titanium Found');
PinningTrustManager.checkServerTrusted.implementation = function() {
quiet_send('Appcelerator checkServerTrusted() called. Not throwing an exception.');
}
} catch (err) {
// If we dont have a ClassNotFoundException exception, raise the
// problem encountered.
if (err.message.indexOf('ClassNotFoundException') === 0) {
throw new Error(err);
}
}
/*** okhttp unpinning ***/
try {
var OkHttpClient = Java.use("com.squareup.okhttp.OkHttpClient");
OkHttpClient.setCertificatePinner.implementation = function(certificatePinner) {
// do nothing
quiet_send("OkHttpClient.setCertificatePinner Called!");
return this;
};
// Invalidate the certificate pinnet checks (if "setCertificatePinner" was called before the previous invalidation)
var CertificatePinner = Java.use("com.squareup.okhttp.CertificatePinner");
CertificatePinner.check.overload('java.lang.String', '[Ljava.security.cert.Certificate;').implementation = function(p0, p1) {
// do nothing
quiet_send("okhttp Called! [Certificate]");
return;
};
CertificatePinner.check.overload('java.lang.String', 'java.util.List').implementation = function(p0, p1) {
// do nothing
quiet_send("okhttp Called! [List]");
return;
};
} catch (e) {
quiet_send("com.squareup.okhttp not found");
}
/*** WebView Hooks ***/
/* frameworks/base/core/java/android/webkit/WebViewClient.java */
/* public void onReceivedSslError(Webview, SslErrorHandler, SslError) */
var WebViewClient = Java.use("android.webkit.WebViewClient");
WebViewClient.onReceivedSslError.implementation = function(webView, sslErrorHandler, sslError) {
quiet_send("WebViewClient onReceivedSslError invoke");
//执行proceed方法
sslErrorHandler.proceed();
return;
};
WebViewClient.onReceivedError.overload('android.webkit.WebView', 'int', 'java.lang.String', 'java.lang.String').implementation = function(a, b, c, d) {
quiet_send("WebViewClient onReceivedError invoked");
return;
};
WebViewClient.onReceivedError.overload('android.webkit.WebView', 'android.webkit.WebResourceRequest', 'android.webkit.WebResourceError').implementation = function() {
quiet_send("WebViewClient onReceivedError invoked");
return;
};
/*** JSSE Hooks ***/
/* libcore/luni/src/main/java/javax/net/ssl/TrustManagerFactory.java */
/* public final TrustManager[] getTrustManager() */
/* TrustManagerFactory.getTrustManagers maybe cause X509TrustManagerExtensions error */
// var TrustManagerFactory = Java.use("javax.net.ssl.TrustManagerFactory");
// TrustManagerFactory.getTrustManagers.implementation = function(){
// quiet_send("TrustManagerFactory getTrustManagers invoked");
// return TrustManagers;
// }
var HttpsURLConnection = Java.use("javax.net.ssl.HttpsURLConnection");
/* libcore/luni/src/main/java/javax/net/ssl/HttpsURLConnection.java */
/* public void setDefaultHostnameVerifier(HostnameVerifier) */
HttpsURLConnection.setDefaultHostnameVerifier.implementation = function(hostnameVerifier) {
quiet_send("HttpsURLConnection.setDefaultHostnameVerifier invoked");
return null;
};
/* libcore/luni/src/main/java/javax/net/ssl/HttpsURLConnection.java */
/* public void setSSLSocketFactory(SSLSocketFactory) */
HttpsURLConnection.setSSLSocketFactory.implementation = function(SSLSocketFactory) {
quiet_send("HttpsURLConnection.setSSLSocketFactory invoked");
return null;
};
/* libcore/luni/src/main/java/javax/net/ssl/HttpsURLConnection.java */
/* public void setHostnameVerifier(HostnameVerifier) */
HttpsURLConnection.setHostnameVerifier.implementation = function(hostnameVerifier) {
quiet_send("HttpsURLConnection.setHostnameVerifier invoked");
return null;
};
/*** Xutils3.x hooks ***/
//Implement a new HostnameVerifier
var TrustHostnameVerifier;
try {
TrustHostnameVerifier = Java.registerClass({
name: 'org.wooyun.TrustHostnameVerifier',
implements: [HostnameVerifier],
method: {
verify: function(hostname, session) {
return true;
}
}
});
} catch (e) {
//java.lang.ClassNotFoundException: Didn't find class "org.wooyun.TrustHostnameVerifier"
quiet_send("registerClass from hostnameVerifier >>>>>>>> " + e.message);
}
try {
var RequestParams = Java.use('org.xutils.http.RequestParams');
RequestParams.setSslSocketFactory.implementation = function(sslSocketFactory) {
sslSocketFactory = EmptySSLFactory;
return null;
}
RequestParams.setHostnameVerifier.implementation = function(hostnameVerifier) {
hostnameVerifier = TrustHostnameVerifier.$new();
return null;
}
} catch (e) {
quiet_send("Xutils hooks not Found");
}
/*** httpclientandroidlib Hooks ***/
try {
var AbstractVerifier = Java.use("ch.boye.httpclientandroidlib.conn.ssl.AbstractVerifier");
AbstractVerifier.verify.overload('java.lang.String', '[Ljava.lang.String', '[Ljava.lang.String', 'boolean').implementation = function() {
quiet_send("httpclientandroidlib Hooks");
return null;
}
} catch (e) {
quiet_send("httpclientandroidlib Hooks not found");
}
/***
android 7.0+ network_security_config TrustManagerImpl hook
apache httpclient partly
***/
var TrustManagerImpl = Java.use("com.android.org.conscrypt.TrustManagerImpl");
// try {
// var Arrays = Java.use("java.util.Arrays");
// //apache http client pinning maybe baypass
// //https://github.com/google/conscrypt/blob/c88f9f55a523f128f0e4dace76a34724bfa1e88c/platform/src/main/java/org/conscrypt/TrustManagerImpl.java#471
// TrustManagerImpl.checkTrusted.implementation = function (chain, authType, session, parameters, authType) {
// quiet_send("TrustManagerImpl checkTrusted called");
// //Generics currently result in java.lang.Object
// return Arrays.asList(chain);
// }
//
// } catch (e) {
// quiet_send("TrustManagerImpl checkTrusted nout found");
// }
try {
// Android 7+ TrustManagerImpl
TrustManagerImpl.verifyChain.implementation = function(untrustedChain, trustAnchorChain, host, clientAuth, ocspData, tlsSctData) {
quiet_send("TrustManagerImpl verifyChain called");
// Skip all the logic and just return the chain again :P
//https://www.nccgroup.trust/uk/about-us/newsroom-and-events/blogs/2017/november/bypassing-androids-network-security-configuration/
// https://github.com/google/conscrypt/blob/c88f9f55a523f128f0e4dace76a34724bfa1e88c/platform/src/main/java/org/conscrypt/TrustManagerImpl.java#L650
return untrustedChain;
}
} catch (e) {
quiet_send("TrustManagerImpl verifyChain nout found below 7.0");
}
// OpenSSLSocketImpl
try {
var OpenSSLSocketImpl = Java.use('com.android.org.conscrypt.OpenSSLSocketImpl');
OpenSSLSocketImpl.verifyCertificateChain.implementation = function(certRefs, authMethod) {
quiet_send('OpenSSLSocketImpl.verifyCertificateChain');
}
quiet_send('OpenSSLSocketImpl pinning')
} catch (err) {
quiet_send('OpenSSLSocketImpl pinner not found');
}
// Trustkit
try {
var Activity = Java.use("com.datatheorem.android.trustkit.pinning.OkHostnameVerifier");
Activity.verify.overload('java.lang.String', 'javax.net.ssl.SSLSession').implementation = function(str) {
quiet_send('Trustkit.verify1: ' + str);
return true;
};
Activity.verify.overload('java.lang.String', 'java.security.cert.X509Certificate').implementation = function(str) {
quiet_send('Trustkit.verify2: ' + str);
return true;
};
quiet_send('Trustkit pinning')
} catch (err) {
quiet_send('Trustkit pinner not found')
}
try {
//cronet pinner hook
//weibo don't invoke
var netBuilder = Java.use("org.chromium.net.CronetEngine$Builder");
//https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/connectivity/cronet/reference/org/chromium/net/CronetEngine.Builder.html#enablePublicKeyPinningBypassForLocalTrustAnchors(boolean)
netBuilder.enablePublicKeyPinningBypassForLocalTrustAnchors.implementation = function(arg) {
//weibo not invoke
console.log("Enables or disables public key pinning bypass for local trust anchors = " + arg);
//true to enable the bypass, false to disable.
var ret = netBuilder.enablePublicKeyPinningBypassForLocalTrustAnchors.call(this, true);
return ret;
};
netBuilder.addPublicKeyPins.implementation = function(hostName, pinsSha256, includeSubdomains, expirationDate) {
console.log("cronet addPublicKeyPins hostName = " + hostName);
//var ret = netBuilder.addPublicKeyPins.call(this,hostName, pinsSha256,includeSubdomains, expirationDate);
//this 是调用 addPublicKeyPins 前的对象吗? Yes,CronetEngine.Builder
return this;
};
} catch (err) {
console.log('[-] Cronet pinner not found')
}
});
4.用了大佬的脚本后,发现还是不行,还是失败了,只能换一个再试试了,又尝试了justtrustme,地址:https://github.com/Fuzion24/JustTrustMe,结果还是不行。
5.在辗转反侧之时,我想起之前用算法助手时,里面带着一个justtruatme的升级版,于是就拿来试了试,结果成功拿下。可以正常进行抓包了。
6.经过上述尝试,我们针对sslpinning这种,可以先用市面上已有的sslunpinning工具进行尝试,如果遇到都无法进行成功的情况,那就需要我们去手工进行hook了,大致有两种思路,一是对所有HTTP字符串相关类进行Hook,二是考虑到App在验证证书时会打开证书文件判断是否是App自身所信任的,因此一定会使用File类的构造函数打开证书文件获得文件的句柄,所以我们在测试时可以Hook上所有File类的构造函数,即对File.$init函数进行hook。这里我用了objection进行hook的:objection -N -h 127.0.0.1 -p 26666-g cn.ticktick.task explore -P ~/.objection/plugins -s "android hooking watch class_method java.io.File.$init --dump-args --dump-backtrace --dump-return",这里因为$在命令行中有特殊含义,所以用对它进行转义,避免被当成命令行变量。hook之后,我们在得到的数据里面搜索/system/etc/security/cacerts
7.我们在搜到的数据里面,找到了一个关于证书的堆栈信息,我们用jadx反编译后,找到这个方法
8.复制一下,丢给chatgpt分析一下,得出结论,这段代码是关于处理 SSL 证书验证的逻辑,是基于域名和证书的哈希值进行匹配,检查传入的证书是否符合某些预期的标准,那我们尝试hook它,并让它返回空,这样不就能绕过证书校验了嘛。
function main() {
Java.perform(function () {
console.log("启动");
let f = Java.use("ll.f");
f["a"].implementation = function (str, list) {
console.log(`f.a is called: str=${str}, list=${list}`);
return;
};
});
}
setTimeout(main, 500)
9.非常幸运,经过hook后,我们成功抓到了这个数据包,至此完成。
三、双向证书认证:服务器校验客户端证书。
1.这是第三种情况,我们以便利蜂app为例,进行抓包尝试,经过尝试,还是和之前一样报错:SSL handshake with client failed: An unknown issue occurred processing the certificate (certificate_unknown)
2.我们先使用objection的android sslpinning disable把这个sslpinning过掉,过掉之后,我们再抓包,发现请求正常发出,响应返回报错:400 No required SSL certificate was sent。判断为服务器校验客户端证书。
3.当我们遇到这种情况,需要我们从app中找到内置的客户端证书,导入到抓包工具中,才能正常进行抓包,那怎么才能找到客户端的证书呢?通常是有二种方法,第一种是用r0ysue大佬写的r0capture进行hook导出,第二种是去hook Keystore,找到加载证书的地方,手动分析源码去找到证书和密码。我们先用一下第一种方案:直接上r0capture,有枣没枣打一杆子试试。
4.运气不错,证书找到了,我们直接在dowload目录下把证书拿出来,安装到Charles里
5.然后,再次进行抓包,可以看到,我们成功绕过了双向证书认证。
6.我们去看一下r0ysue大佬的脚本,简单来解释一下原理,在安卓开发中,系统包是无法混淆的,例如java.security.KeyStore不会被混淆,所以可以去hook这个类,并且在 Java 中,KeyStore$PrivateKeyEntry 是存储在 KeyStore 中,包含私鑰和相關的證書,即getPrivateKey() 和 getCertificateChain() 這兩個方法,也就是说当應用程序調用 getPrivateKey() 或 getCertificateChain() 方法來獲取私鑰和證書時,会被脚本拦截并提取返回的私钥和证书数据,然后storeP12() 函數,將提取的私鑰和證書組合起來,存儲為一個 .p12 文件,并使用密码r0ysue進行加密並寫入到指定的文件路徑。
Java.perform(function () {
function uuid(len, radix) {
var chars = '0123456789ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz'.split('');
var uuid = [], i;
radix = radix || chars.length;
if (len) {
// Compact form
for (i = 0; i < len; i++) uuid[i] = chars[0 | Math.random() * radix];
} else {
// rfc4122, version 4 form
var r;
// rfc4122 requires these characters
uuid[8] = uuid[13] = uuid[18] = uuid[23] = '-';
uuid[14] = '4';
// Fill in random data. At i==19 set the high bits of clock sequence as
// per rfc4122, sec. 4.1.5
for (i = 0; i < 36; i++) {
if (!uuid[i]) {
r = 0 | Math.random() * 16;
uuid[i] = chars[(i == 19) ? (r & 0x3) | 0x8 : r];
}
}
}
return uuid.join('');
}
function storeP12(pri, p7, p12Path, p12Password) {
var X509Certificate = Java.use("java.security.cert.X509Certificate")
var p7X509 = Java.cast(p7, X509Certificate);
var chain = Java.array("java.security.cert.X509Certificate", [p7X509])
var ks = Java.use("java.security.KeyStore").getInstance("PKCS12", "BC");
ks.load(null, null);
ks.setKeyEntry("client", pri, Java.use('java.lang.String').$new(p12Password).toCharArray(), chain);
try {
var out = Java.use("java.io.FileOutputStream").$new(p12Path);
ks.store(out, Java.use('java.lang.String').$new(p12Password).toCharArray())
} catch (exp) {
console.log(exp)
}
}
// 在服务器校验客户端的情形下,帮助dump客户端证书,并保存为p12的格式,证书密码为r0ysue
Java.use("java.security.KeyStore$PrivateKeyEntry").getPrivateKey.implementation = function () {
var result = this.getPrivateKey()
var packageName = Java.use("android.app.ActivityThread").currentApplication().getApplicationContext().getPackageName();
storeP12(this.getPrivateKey(), this.getCertificate(), '/sdcard/Download/' + packageName + uuid(10, 16) + '.p12', 'r0ysue');
return result;
}
Java.use("java.security.KeyStore$PrivateKeyEntry").getCertificateChain.implementation = function () {
var result = this.getCertificateChain()
var packageName = Java.use("android.app.ActivityThread").currentApplication().getApplicationContext().getPackageName();
storeP12(this.getPrivateKey(), this.getCertificate(), '/sdcard/Download/' + packageName + uuid(10, 16) + '.p12', 'r0ysue');
return result;
}
});
7.这个便利蜂的例子到此为止,我们再拿出上次我们折腾过的Fake Location,它也是双向证书认证,这次我们自己去找一下证书,还是一样启动charles进行抓包。
8.可以看到,报错和之前是一样的,我们之前说过了,这种是sslpinning的情况,我们用objection的android sslpinning disable把它过掉,过掉之后,再重新抓包,发现报错变了,请求包正常,响应包400的情况。
9.这种情况就是双向证书校验了,我们需要去解包找证书搜索.p12,.bks,.pem,还是一样没找到,我们只能去脱壳反编译代码,这次脱壳我用的是大佬给分享的一个脱壳网站:https://nop.gs/
10.然后我们去代码里找找看,这里我们直接搜索keystore,发现就这几个,而且就这俩货带着BKS的关键字样。
11.点进去看看,终于知道为啥我解包后,搜索常见证书后缀搜不着的原因了,原来是用了图片做证书。md
12.证书找到了,接下来就是找密码了,怎么找呢?当然是hook了,上脚本。之前也说过了,因为java.security.KeyStore是系统的类是不会被混淆的,所以我们hook它就行了。
function hook_KeyStore_load() {
Java.perform(function () {
var StringClass = Java.use("java.lang.String");
var KeyStore = Java.use("java.security.KeyStore");
KeyStore.load.overload('java.security.KeyStore$LoadStoreParameter').implementation = function (arg0) {
// printStack("KeyStore.load1");
// 输出调用栈
console.log(Java.use("android.util.Log").getStackTraceString(Java.use("java.lang.Throwable").$new()));
console.log("KeyStore.load1:", arg0);
this.load(arg0);
};
KeyStore.load.overload('java.io.InputStream', '[C').implementation = function (arg0, arg1) {
// printStack("KeyStore.load2");
console.log(Java.use("android.util.Log").getStackTraceString(Java.use("java.lang.Throwable").$new()));
console.log("KeyStore.load2:", arg0, arg1 ? StringClass.$new(arg1) : null);
this.load(arg0, arg1);
};
console.log("hook_KeyStore_load...");
});
}
hook_KeyStore_load()
13.来,让我们来看看hook的效果如何?hook出来了,密码是lerist.key.2021
14.然后我们把证书拿出来
15.这里我用了keystore explorer对证书进行格式的转换
16.我们得把证书转成p12格式,才能在charles里安装,安装完成后,虽然是加密得,但是可以正常抓包了。
四、总结
在Android应用的抓包过程中,处理不同类型的证书验证机制的方法有所不同:
无证书校验:如果应用没有进行证书验证,我们只需配置抓包工具的证书即可进行抓包。
单向证书认证(SSL Pinning):对于SSL Pinning的应用,我们通常需要使用Frida等工具进行hook,以绕过SSL Pinning机制。在某些情况下,可能需要尝试多种方法,如使用JustTrustMe脚本,才能成功进行抓包。
双向证书认证:对于双向证书认证,我们可以使用r0capture直接dump证书。此外,也可以通过代码中找到证书和密码,然后将其转换为.p12证书,并导入到抓包工具中进行抓包。
原文始发于微信公众号(Flower Sec):Android app抓包场景详解
- 左青龙
- 微信扫一扫
-
- 右白虎
- 微信扫一扫
-
评论